
| News
Ahmed Ben Musa Writes: “Sound Economic Policies Generally Require Supporting Production Rather Than Consumption”
Businessman Ahmed Ben Musa wrote in an article:
Sound economic policies generally call for supporting production rather than consumption. Supporting production gradually leads to an increase in gross domestic product (GDP), higher average per capita income, lower unemployment rates, improved workforce skills and productivity, the localisation of knowledge and technology, reduced dependence on imports, expanded export opportunities, and an improvement in the country’s trade balance.
All these factors naturally lead to an improvement in citizens’ living standards, lifting many people from lower-income groups into the middle class, and achieving the economic prosperity to which every society aspires.
By contrast, subsidising consumption generally creates harmful consumption habits that become entrenched over time. When fuel and electricity become cheaper than water, people stop calculating how much they consume. Engines are left running unnecessarily, cars are used for even the shortest journeys, air conditioners and appliances operate around the clock, and energy is wasted because its cost is barely felt by anyone. Eventually, wastefulness becomes an accepted social behaviour.
A culture of conservation and efficiency dies before it can even take root. These habits then become a burden on the economy, the environment, and future generations.
Since these resources are sold domestically for less than their actual value, society loses twice: first, when its finite wealth is burned at a negligible price; and second, when it is deprived of the opportunity to export these resources at international market prices.
Even worse, the substantial gap between domestic and international prices creates wide opportunities for fuel smuggling. Fuel stations turn into queues and recurring shortage crises, the cost of which is borne by ordinary citizens, while organised smuggling networks grow through money and influence, eating away at state institutions through corruption. Subsidies end up in the pockets of smugglers rather than reaching those entitled to them, and the country’s wealth is plundered right from under its people’s feet.
The damage does not stop there. Subsidies inject money into the market without corresponding increases in actual production. This drives up demand for imported goods, inflates the import bill, depletes foreign currency reserves, fuels inflation, and reduces the purchasing power of the very citizens who believe these subsidies were introduced to protect them.
Subsidies also burden the state budget with accumulating obligations that are politically difficult to reverse. They create a culture of dependency that weakens the incentives to work, take initiative, innovate, and establish businesses. The result is an economy that consumes more than it produces, depends on foreign markets to meet even its most basic needs, and remains hostage to fluctuations in oil prices and global markets. What once appeared to be prosperity was, in fact, nothing more than deferred debt whose cost we are paying today and will continue to pay tomorrow.
One of the paradoxes of consumption subsidies is that, although they are introduced in the name of helping the poor, the largest share actually goes to the wealthy. In practice, subsidies are distributed according to consumption levels: the more a person consumes, the greater their benefit.
The owner of a large villa, offices air-conditioned throughout the day, and countless cars receives the largest share of subsidised fuel and electricity. Meanwhile, a low-income family living in a small home, owning only one old car—or no car at all—receives next to nothing.
Even worse, this same family bears the cost of wastefulness through inflation and rising prices. It is the family that stands in queues and resorts to the black market when supplies run short, while wealthy people have the means to secure their needs regardless of what happens.
In other words, those who need subsidies most benefit the least, while those who do not need them at all benefit the most.
Social justice cannot possibly be achieved under such a system, which continuously transfers the country’s wealth from the majority to a minority. Genuine subsidies should reach those who deserve them by directing assistance straight to the most vulnerable groups and creating jobs and productive opportunities that enable them to move from dependency to self-sufficiency.
Economic history demonstrates that replacing subsidies is not only possible but can also be successful when implemented intelligently.
In Mexico, for example, the government launched the “Progresa” programme in 1997, replacing general food subsidies with cash transfers linked to specific conditions, such as sending children to school and ensuring they receive regular healthcare. Under this system, funds were redirected from ineffective subsidies into a programme that genuinely reached the poor. The same model was subsequently replicated in dozens of countries around the world.
In Indonesia, for instance, the removal of subsidies in 2005 increased fuel prices by an average of more than 125%. However, the government did not leave people to fend for themselves. It provided cash transfers to approximately 20 million households, representing roughly one-third of the population, following a needs assessment.
In 2014, the country’s president again abolished petrol subsidies entirely. This enabled the government to save more than 10% of total public expenditure and redirect the funds towards infrastructure, healthcare, education, and rural communities—all investments that build productive capacity rather than burn fuel. This came particularly after studies demonstrated how unjust the old subsidy system had been: the poorest half of the population received only around 20% of the subsidy budget under the previous system.
In India, cooking gas cylinders were sold to everyone at subsidised prices, turning them into commodities vulnerable to smuggling, manipulation, and fictitious invoices. The government subsequently introduced the PAHAL programme, under which cylinders were sold at market prices while the subsidy amount was transferred directly into the bank account of the actual consumer.
As a result, more than 33 million fraudulent gas connections were eliminated, saving the Indian government billions of dollars that had previously gone into the pockets of smugglers and speculators, without depriving eligible beneficiaries of their entitlements.
What these experiences have in common is that they did not simply abolish subsidies and withdraw support. Instead, they shifted assistance from the commodity to the individual. The changes were announced to the public in advance, the most vulnerable groups were compensated before prices were raised, databases were established to identify eligible beneficiaries, and the savings were redirected towards initiatives that increase production and income.
The problem was never helping the poor; it was the way the programmes intended to help them were designed.
Ultimately, the bigger picture is simpler than we might think.
Consumption subsidies treat the economy as though it were a fixed-size pie: all we do is cut it into slices and distribute them, only to repeat the process every year with smaller slices because the pie never grows—it is simply consumed.
Supporting production, however, begins with a different question: How can we make the pie itself bigger, so that everyone’s share grows without anyone having to lose anything?
A dinar invested in a factory, a training workshop, a road, a start-up, or an export-oriented sector is not simply consumed; it multiplies. It creates a job, that job pays a salary, the salary is spent in the market, and the market generates demand for more production. The cycle continues and expands rather than gradually eroding.
Countries that achieved prosperity did not do so by chance. They succeeded when they decided to transform their finite wealth into assets that generate sustainable income, rather than burning it as cheap fuel that provides light today but goes out tomorrow.
The question we should be asking is not how much we subsidise, but what we build with the resources we devote to subsidies.
Subsidies that build nothing are expenditure; subsidies that build productive capacity are investment.
Nations do not prosper by distributing what they already have, but by multiplying it.

